Inicio  /  Water  /  Vol: 10 Par: 4 (2018)  /  Artículo
ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Uncertainty of Rainfall Products: Impact on Modelling Household Nutrition from Rain-Fed Agriculture in Southern Africa

Robert Luetkemeier    
Lina Stein    
Lukas Drees    
Hannes Müller and Stefan Liehr    

Resumen

Good quality data on precipitation are a prerequisite for applications like short-term weather forecasts, medium-term humanitarian assistance, and long-term climate modelling. In Sub-Saharan Africa, however, the meteorological station networks are frequently insufficient, as in the Cuvelai-Basin in Namibia and Angola. This paper analyses six rainfall products (ARC2.0, CHIRPS2.0, CRU-TS3.23, GPCCv7, PERSIANN-CDR, and TAMSAT) with respect to their performance in a crop model (APSIM) to obtain nutritional scores of a household?s requirements for dietary energy and further macronutrients. All products were calibrated to an observed time series using Quantile Mapping. The crop model output was compared against official yield data. The results show that the products (i) reproduce well the Basin?s spatial patterns, and (ii) temporally agree to station records (r = 0.84). However, differences exist in absolute annual rainfall (range: 154 mm), rainfall intensities, dry spell duration, rainy day counts, and the rainy season onset. Though calibration aligns key characteristics, the remaining differences lead to varying crop model results. While the model well reproduces official yield data using the observed rainfall time series (r = 0.52), the products? results are heterogeneous (e.g., CHIRPS: r = 0.18). Overall, 97% of a household?s dietary energy demand is met. The study emphasizes the importance of considering the differences among multiple rainfall products when ground measurements are scarce.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Hadis Pakdel, Dev Raj Paudyal, Sreeni Chadalavada, Md Jahangir Alam and Majid Vazifedoust    
The frequency and severity of extremes, including extreme precipitation events, extreme evapotranspiration and extreme water storage deficit events, are changing. Thus, the necessity for developing a framework that estimates non-stationary conditions is ... ver más

 
Faisal Baig, Mohsen Sherif and Muhammad Abrar Faiz    
Mountainous watersheds have always been a challenge for modelers due to large variability and insufficient ground observations, which cause forcing data, model structure, and parameter uncertainty. This study employed Differential Evolution Adaptive Metr... ver más
Revista: Hydrology

 
Amin Minaei, Sara Todeschini, Robert Sitzenfrei and Enrico Creaco    
Climate change increasingly is affecting every aspect of human life on the earth. Many regional climate models (RCMs) have so far been developed to carefully assess this important phenomenon on specific regions. In this study, ten RCMs captured from the ... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Hanbeen Kim, Taereem Kim, Ju-Young Shin and Jun-Haeng Heo    
Extreme value modeling for extreme rainfall is one of the most important processes in the field of hydrology. For the improvement of extreme value modeling and its physical meaning, large-scale climate modes have been widely used as covariates of distrib... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Andreas Efstratiadis, Panagiotis Dimas, George Pouliasis, Ioannis Tsoukalas, Panagiotis Kossieris, Vasilis Bellos, Georgia-Konstantina Sakki, Christos Makropoulos and Spyridon Michas    
We propose a novel probabilistic approach to flood hazard assessment, aiming to address the major shortcomings of everyday deterministic engineering practices in a computationally efficient manner. In this context, the principal sources of uncertainty ar... ver más
Revista: Water