Inicio  /  Water  /  Vol: 9 Núm: 8 Par: 0 (2017)  /  Artículo
ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Comparison of SWAT and GWLF Model Simulation Performance in Humid South and Semi-Arid North of China

Zuoda Qi    
Gelin Kang    
Chunli Chu    
Yu Qiu    
Ze Xu    
Yuqiu Wang    

Resumen

Watershed models have gradually been adapted to support both decision and policy making for global environmental pollution control. In this study, two watershed models with different complexity, the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) and the Generalized Watershed Loading Function (GWLF), were applied in two catchments in data scarce China, namely the Tunxi and the Hanjiaying basins with contrasting climatic conditions (humid and semi-arid, respectively). The performances of both models were assessed via comparison between simulated and measured monthly streamflow, sediment yield, and total nitrogen. Time series plots as well as four statistical measures (the coefficient of determination (R2), the Nash?Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE), percent bias (PBIAS), and RMSE (root mean square error)?observations standard deviation ratio (RSR)) were used to estimate the performance of both models. The results show that both models were generally able to simulate monthly streamflow, sediment, and total nitrogen loadings during the simulation period. However, SWAT performed better for detailed representations, while GWLF could produce much better average values of the observed data. Thus, GWLF offers a user-friendly prospective alternative watershed model that requires little input data and that is applicable for areas where the input data required for SWAT are not always available. SWAT is more suitable for projects that require high accuracy and offers an advantage when measured data are scarce.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Dandan Zhang, Mou Leong Tan, Sharifah Rohayah Sheikh Dawood, Narimah Samat, Chun Kiat Chang, Ranjan Roy, Yi Lin Tew and Mohd Amirul Mahamud    
Identification of reliable alternative climate input data for hydrological modelling is important to manage water resources and reduce water-related hazards in ungauged or poorly gauged basins. This study aims to evaluate the capability of the National C... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Prasad Daggupati, Rituraj Shukla, Balew Mekonnen, Ramesh Rudra, Asim Biswas, Pradeep K. Goel, Shiv Prasher and Wanhong Yang    
In the last decade, Lake Erie, one of the great lakes bordering Canada and the USA has been under serious threat due to increased phosphorus levels originating from agricultural fields. Large scale watersheds contributing to Lake Erie from the USA side a... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Youen Grusson, François Anctil, Sabine Sauvage and José Miguel Sánchez Pérez    
Climate change is suspected to impact water circulation within the hydrological cycle at catchment scale. A SWAT model approach to assess the evolution of the many hydrological components of the Garonne catchment (Southern France) is deployed in this stu... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Ying Hao, Jingjin Ma, Jing Chen, Dongyong Wang, Yuan Wang and Hongmei Xu    
The global warming of 1.5 °C and 2.0 °C proposed in the Paris Agreement has become the iconic threshold of climate change impact research. This study aims to assess the potential impact of 1.5 °C and 2.0 °C global warming on water balance components (WBC... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Qin-Bo Cheng, Xi Chen, Jiao Wang, Zhi-Cai Zhang, Run-Run Zhang, Yong-Yu Xie, Christian Reinhardt-Imjela and Achim Schulte    
The soil and water assessment tool (SWAT) is widely used to quantify the spatial and temporal patterns of sediment loads for watershed-scale management of sediment and nonpoint-source pollutants. However few studies considered the trade-off between flow ... ver más
Revista: Water