ARTÍCULO
TITULO

The Qualis effect: A comparative case study of the Brazilian rating system for peer-reviewed journals

Rafael Campos    

Resumen

In recent years, Impact Factor scores have been criticized due to misuse. The growing acceptance of Impact Factor scores in many Brazilian subject areas has created this recent discussion, mainly because Brazil has its own rating system for journals: Qualis. The whole system follows governmental directions under the Ministry of Education, and it has been criticized as a monopolized evaluation system that accepts Impact Factor scores as tools for measuring quality. Despite being under ministerial instruction, each subject area adapts the system, applies Impact Factor scores as a valid measure, or does not accept the scores at all and utilizes other ways to measure qualified journals. Here, we will attempt to show that the Brazilian system is more complex than previously thought. We will also advocate for the possible adoption of a rating system that does not follow any kind of metric system for rating journals. To conclude, we will address the fact that what has to change in Brazil is the unrealistic use of Impact Factor scores, rather than the whole governmental system.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Melody R. Mukandi, Moses Basitere, Seteno K. O. Ntwampe, Mahomet Njoya, Boredi S. Chidi, Cynthia Dlangamandla and Ncumisa Mpongwana    
The poultry industry generates significant volumes of slaughterhouse wastewater, laden with numerous pollutants, thus requiring pretreatment prior to discharge. However, new technologies must be used to re-engineer the existing wastewater treatment equip... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Chen Xia, Christian Eduardo Verdonk Gallego, Adrián Fabio Bracero, Víctor Fernando Gómez Comendador and Rosa María Arnaldo Valdés    
This paper investigates the impact of trajectory predictor performance on the encounter probability generated by an adaptive conflict detection tool and examines the flexibility of the tool dependent on its adjustable thresholds, using historical radar t... ver más
Revista: Aerospace

 
Krzysztof Tomczuk, Piotr Tomczuk and Marcin Chrzanowicz    
A properly designed and manufactured autonomous lighting system has an impact on reducing the amount of conflicts between pedestrians and drivers. For pedestrian crossings located outside of urban areas, one of the utilized solutions is PV installations ... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Matharit Namsai, Butsawan Bidorn, Ruetaitip Mama and Warit Charoenlerkthawin    
The construction of large dams in the upper tributary basin of the Chao Phraya River (CPR) has been linked to a significant decrease in sediment load in the CPR system, estimated between 75?85%. This study, utilizing historical and recent river flow and ... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Joana Carneiro, Dália Loureiro, Marta Cabral and Dídia Covas    
This paper presents and demonstrates a novel scenario-building methodology that integrates contextual and future time uncertainty into the performance assessment of water distribution networks (WDNs). A three-step approach is proposed: (i) System context... ver más
Revista: Water