ARTÍCULO
TITULO

A Prediction Accuracy-Practicality Tradeoff Analysis of the State-of-the-art Safety Performance Assessment Methods

Jaehyun So    
Silja Hoffmann    
Joyoung Lee    
Fritz Busch    
Keechoo Choi    

Resumen

This study proposes advanced safety assessment methods in the perspectives of prediction performance and practicality. This study thus develops three different safety assessment approaches (simulated conflicts-incorporated, estimated conflicts-incorporated, and intersection operational attributes-based safety performance function) and utilizes two existing approaches (annual average daily traffic-based and simulated conflicts-based safety performance functions. These five safety assessment approaches are compared in terms of crash prediction performance at intersections and practicality representing the required efforts in implementing a method. The results showed that the simulated conflicts-incorporated safety performance function approach was best in terms of prediction performance while the annual average daily traffic-based safety performance function approach was best in the practicality aspect. The discussion on trade-off between prediction performance and practicality then followed based on the analysis on the prediction performance and practicality aspects. This study will be a reference to safety assessment practitioners when they need to assess safety on roadways and to select an appropriate safety assessment method with limited resources.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Fraser King, Miroslav Kolàr, Scott Briggs, Mehran Behazin, Peter Keech and Nikitas Diomidis    
The disposal of high-level radioactive waste (HLW) and spent nuclear fuel (SF) presents a unique challenge for the prediction of the long-term performance of corrodible structures since HLW/SF containers are expected, in some cases, to have lifetimes of ... ver más

 
Jiantao Qu, Chunyu Qi and He Meng    
Within the Shuo Huang Railway Company (Suning, China ) the long-term evolution for railways (LTE-R) network carries core wireless communication services for trains. The communication performance of LTE-R cells directly affects the operational safety of t... ver más
Revista: Future Internet

 
Emin Aktan, Ivan Bartoli, Branko Gli?ic and Carlo Rainieri    
This paper summarizes the lessons learned after several decades of exploring and applying Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) in operating bridge structures. The challenges in real-time imaging and processing of large amounts of sensor data at various ban... ver más
Revista: Infrastructures

 
Woo-Hyun Choi and Jung-Ho Lewe    
This study proposes a deep learning model utilizing the BACnet (Building Automation and Control Network) protocol for the real-time detection of mechanical faults and security vulnerabilities in building automation systems. Integrating various machine le... ver más
Revista: Buildings

 
Rehan Masood    
Prefabricated construction is expanding and taking over traditional construction with more intervention of prefabricated building elements. Despite prefabricated construction reducing health and safety risks compared to conventional construction, there i... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences