ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Labeling or science-by-buzzwords: The semantic trap in academic research and how to get out of it

Klaus Solberg Söilen    

Resumen

The social sciences are drowning in new fancy academic terms or buzzwords, labels with unprecise definitions, rebranding phenomenon that somehow seem familiar. We are all surrounded by smart cities, innovation, and sustainability. What do these terms mean that we could not express earlier? Introducingthem also raises new questions, which at first may seem provocative: Are there dumb cities too, if sowhere? Do we carry out research at our universities that is not innovative? Does the literature onsustainability make our products more sustainable? Above all, these new fields are formulated in almostsuspiciously positive terms attracting the attention of our politicians and echoed everywhere. How cananyone be against smart cities, innovation and sustainability? It must be good, important and thereforeit deserves funding. To become more relevant academic research must redirect its focus from buzzwords to problems, notjust smart ?research gaps? in the literature. Instead of listing keywords, researchers, academic journalsand academic databases should list problems (1), and the problems should be stated in full sentences (2)using as few (3) and as simple words as possible (4). We should also insist on clear, mutually exclusivedefinitions. By searching for problems instead of labels it will become much easier to find relevantresearch across different labels and disciplines.We need to be much stricter when admitting new labels. If a new term is not exact and not muchdifferent from a previous term it should be declined. Focus should be on what the Germans since the 19thcentury understand by ?verstehen?, as the "interpretive or participatory" examination of socialphenomena, not on coining new terms. Today new terms often come to life because we did not readenough, or we thought more about internal marketing and our own self-promotion instead of focusing onproblems that are important for humanity. We are all guilty of this to a certain degree as it?s difficult toescape the logic trap that is our current social science research system.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Huiyan Wu and Jun Huang    
The main purpose of the joint entity and relation extraction is to extract entities from unstructured texts and extract the relation between labeled entities at the same time. At present, most existing joint entity and relation extraction networks ignore... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Chen Chen, Xin Jiang, Shu Miao, Weiguo Zhou and Yunhui Liu    
In the industrial domain, estimating the pose of texture-less shiny parts is challenging but worthwhile. In this study, it is impractical to utilize texture information to obtain the pose because the features are likely to be affected by the surrounding ... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Dongwei Qiu, Haorong Liang, Zhilin Wang, Yuci Tong and Shanshan Wan    
Quickly and accurately identifying water leakage is one of the important components of the health monitoring of subway tunnels. A mobile vision measurement system consisting of several high-resolution, industrial, charge-coupled device (CCD) cameras is p... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Shinjin Kang and Jong-in Choi    
On the game screen, the UI interface provides key information for game play. A vision deep learning network exploits pure pixel information in the screen. Apart from this, if we separately extract the information provided by the UI interface and use it a... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Jaehui Park    
Semantic role labeling is an effective approach to understand underlying meanings associated with word relationships in natural language sentences. Recent studies using deep neural networks, specifically, recurrent neural networks, have significantly imp... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences