ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Interactive mapping for public transit planning: Comparing accessibility and travel-time framings

Anson Stewart    
P. Christopher Zegras    

Resumen

As transport planners increasingly frame project impacts in accessibility terms, it is worth considering how this foundational land-use transport interaction concept can shape stakeholder attitudes. In this paper, we test whether framing the benefits of public transit projects in terms of increased accessibility better fosters enthusiasm among advocates, as compared to framing benefits in terms of travel-time savings. We test two versions of an interactive mapping tool in small workshops examining upgraded bus services. One version shows isochrones and accessibility indicators, and the other shows paths and travel time indicators. Results from pre- and post-surveys suggest that framing impacts in accessibility terms may encourage broader thinking and stronger dialog than framing impacts in time-savings terms. In particular, the accessibility version seems to mitigate skepticism and car users? predispositions against upgrading bus service. An unexpected result is that many workshop participants report decreased overall enthusiasm for the bus upgrades after using either version of the tool. This disappointment may stem from an unrealistic baseline, which assumes perfect schedule adherence not aligned with lived experiences. Future research should consider tools that help stakeholders understand and deliberate about actual service and network-level reliability, and testing such tools with wider audiences.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Feiyan Yu, Erik Champion and David McMeekin    
The Australian Time Layered Cultural Map platform was created to help digital humanities scholars investigate how online geospatial tools could provide exemplars to their humanities colleagues on how historical collections and cultural data could be exte... ver más

 
Manar Ahmed Hamza, Hamed Alqahtani, Dalia H. Elkamchouchi, Hussain Alshahrani, Jaber S. Alzahrani, Mohammed Maray, Mohamed Ahmed Elfaki and Amira Sayed A. Aziz    
Unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) have significant abilities for automatic detection and mapping of urban surface materials due to their high resolution. It requires a massive quantity of data to understand the ground material properties. In recent days, c... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Khalid Oubennaceur, Karem Chokmani, Anas El Alem and Yves Gauthier    
In Canada, flooding is the most common and costly natural hazard. Flooding events significantly impact communities, damage infrastructures and threaten public security. Communication, as part of a flood risk management strategy, is an essential means of ... ver más
Revista: Hydrology

 
Anson Hu and Ibrahim Demir    
The height above nearest drainage (HAND) model is frequently used to calculate properties of the soil and predict flood inundation extents. HAND is extremely useful due to its lack of reliance on prior data, as only the digital elevation model (DEM) is n... ver más
Revista: Hydrology

 
Radek Barvir, Alena Vondrakova and Jan Brus    
Despite the growing efficiency of the map-design process in general, tactile mapping has remained peripheral to mainstream cartography. For a specific group of people with visual impairment, however, tactile maps are the only effective way to obtain a co... ver más