Inicio  /  Algorithms  /  Vol: 16 Par: 9 (2023)  /  Artículo
ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Quantitative and Qualitative Comparison of Decision-Map Techniques for Explaining Classification Models

Yu Wang    
Alister Machado and Alexandru Telea    

Resumen

Visualization techniques for understanding and explaining machine learning models have gained significant attention. One such technique is the decision map, which creates a 2D depiction of the decision behavior of classifiers trained on high-dimensional data. While several decision map techniques have been proposed recently, such as Decision Boundary Maps (DBMs), Supervised Decision Boundary Maps (SDBMs), and DeepView (DV), there is no framework for comprehensively evaluating and comparing these techniques. In this paper, we propose such a framework by combining quantitative metrics and qualitative assessment. We apply our framework to DBM, SDBM, and DV using a range of both synthetic and real-world classification techniques and datasets. Our results show that none of the evaluated decision-map techniques consistently outperforms the others in all measured aspects. Separately, our analysis exposes several previously unknown properties and limitations of decision-map techniques. To support practitioners, we also propose a workflow for selecting the most appropriate decision-map technique for given datasets, classifiers, and requirements of the application at hand.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Mariusz Kluska and Joanna Jablonska    
Due to their toxicity, lack of bioaccumulation and biodegradability, and ease of binding to sediments, heavy metals are considered the main pollutants of rivers. It is, therefore, necessary to control and monitor these pollutants. The present study analy... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Min Wang, Xiaoyu Song, Yu Han, Guantao Ding, Ruilin Zhang, Shanming Wei, Shuai Gao and Yuxiang Liu    
In order to understand the pollution degree and source of potentially toxic elements (PTEs) in groundwater around the accident site and evaluate their harm to human health, 22 groundwater samples were collected around the accident well, and the contents ... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Ye Xiao, Yupeng Hu, Jizhao Liu, Yi Xiao and Qianzhen Liu    
Ship trajectory prediction is essential for ensuring safe route planning and to have advanced warning of the dangers at sea. With the development of deep learning, most of the current research has explored advanced prediction methods based on historical ... ver más

 
Carlos Matos, Pedro Cabrera, José A. Carta and Noemi Melián-Martel    
Water scarcity is a global problem that particularly affects islands located in arid regions or regions with limited water resources. This issue has prompted the development of non-conventional water sources such as fossil fuel-powered desalination syste... ver más

 
Yongzhen Zhang, Yanbo Hui, Ying Zhou, Juanjuan Liu, Ju Gao, Xiaoliang Wang, Baiwei Wang, Mengqi Xie and Haonan Hou    
Moldy corn produces aflatoxin and gibberellin, which can have adverse effects on human health if consumed. Mold is a significant factor that affects the safe storage of corn. If not detected and controlled in a timely manner, it will result in substantia... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences