Inicio  /  Water  /  Vol: 7 Par: 1 (2015)  /  Artículo
ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Comparing Methods of Calculating Expected Annual Damage in Urban Pluvial Flood Risk Assessments

Anders Skovgård Olsen    
Qianqian Zhou    
Jens Jørgen Linde and Karsten Arnbjerg-Nielsen    

Resumen

Estimating the expected annual damage (EAD) due to flooding in an urban area is of great interest for urban water managers and other stakeholders. It is a strong indicator for a given area showing how vulnerable it is to flood risk and how much can be gained by implementing e.g., climate change adaptation measures. This study identifies and compares three different methods for estimating the EAD based on unit costs of flooding of urban assets. One of these methods was used in previous studies and calculates the EAD based on a few extreme events by assuming a log-linear relationship between cost of an event and the corresponding return period. This method is compared to methods that are either more complicated or require more calculations. The choice of method by which the EAD is calculated appears to be of minor importance. At all three case study areas it seems more important that there is a shift in the damage costs as a function of the return period. The shift occurs approximately at the 10 year return period and can perhaps be related to the design criteria for sewer systems. Further, it was tested if the EAD estimation could be simplified by assuming a single unit cost per flooded area. The results indicate that within each catchment this may be a feasible approach. However the unit costs varies substantially between different case study areas. Hence it is not feasible to develop unit costs that can be used to calculate EAD, most likely because the urban landscape is too heterogeneous.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Noelia García, Miguel Gómez-Polo, Miriam Fernández, José Luis Antonaya-Martín, Rocío Ortega, Cristina Gómez-Polo, Marta Revilla-León and Rocío Cascos    
Background: With CAD-CAM, dental models are often fabricated by additive manufacturing (AM) methods. Dental models for implant prostheses involve the manual placement of analogs, which could affect their final fit. Therefore, in this experimental in vitr... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
David Mattie, Zihang Fang, Emi Takahashi, Lourdes Peña Castillo and Jacob Levman    
Diffusion magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) tractography is a powerful tool for non-invasively studying brain architecture and structural integrity by inferring fiber tracts based on water diffusion profiles. This study provided a thorough set of baseline... ver más
Revista: Information

 
Michiel van der Vlag, Lionel Kusch, Alain Destexhe, Viktor Jirsa, Sandra Diaz-Pier and Jennifer S. Goldman    
Global neural dynamics emerge from multi-scale brain structures, with nodes dynamically communicating to form transient ensembles that may represent neural information. Neural activity can be measured empirically at scales spanning proteins and subcellul... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Tamim Mahmud Al-Hasan, Aya Nabil Sayed, Faycal Bensaali, Yassine Himeur, Iraklis Varlamis and George Dimitrakopoulos    
Recommender systems are a key technology for many applications, such as e-commerce, streaming media, and social media. Traditional recommender systems rely on collaborative filtering or content-based filtering to make recommendations. However, these appr... ver más

 
Arjun Poudel, Seungwon Kim, Byoung Hooi Cho and Janghwan Kim    
Composite bridges are typically exposed to temperature variations due to heat radiation, conduction, and convection. Temperature affects the modal parameters of bridges, hindering the application of damage detection methods based on the dynamic propertie... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences