ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Global Digital Elevation Model Comparison Criteria: An Evident Need to Consider Their Application

Carlos López-Vázquez and Francisco Javier Ariza-López    

Resumen

From an extensive search of papers related to the comparison of Global Digital Elevation Models (hereinafter GDEMs), an analysis is carried out that aims to answer several questions such as: Which GDEMs have been compared? Where have the comparisons been made? How many comparisons have been made? How have the assessments been carried out? Which is the GDEM option with the lowest RMSE? Analysis shows that SRTM and ASTER are the most popular GDEMs, that the countries where more comparisons have been made are Brazil, India, and China, and that the main type of reference data for evaluations is the use of points surveyed by GNSS techniques. A variety of criteria have been found for the comparison of GDEMs, but the most used are the RMSE and the standard deviation of the elevation error. There are numerous criteria with a more user-centric character in thematic areas, such as morphometry, geomorphology, erosion, etc. However, in none of the thematic areas does there exist a standard method of comparison. This limits the possibilities of establishing a ranking of GDEMs based on their user-focused quality. In addition, the methods and reference data set are not adequately explained or shared, which limits the interoperability of the studies carried out and the ability to make robust comparisons between them.

Palabras claves

DEM -  GDEM -  SRTM -  ASTER -  NASADEM -  WorldDEM -  MERIT -  ALOS-AW3D30 -  FABDEM

 Artículos similares

       
 
Xunzhi Yin, Chong Guo, Bo Sun, Honggang Chen, Hui Wang and An Li    
Under the trend of digitization and global carbon reductions, clay construction has increasingly attracted attention due to advantages such as an excellent thermal performance, low carbon emissions, and high cost-effectiveness. In this article, an in-dep... ver más
Revista: Buildings

 
Vassilios N. Grigoriadis, Vassilios D. Andritsanos and Dimitrios A. Natsiopoulos    
Recent Digital Surface, Elevation, and Bathymetric Models (DSM/DEM/DBM) aim to provide high-resolution and accurate height and depth information needed for a variety of surveying, geodetic, geophysical, and other applications. In this study, first we aim... ver más

 
Rafael Cabral, Rogério Oliveira, Diogo Ribeiro, Anna M. Rakoczy, Ricardo Santos, Miguel Azenha and José Correia    
Documentation of structural visual inspections is necessary for its monitoring, maintenance, and decision about its rehabilitation, and structural strengthening. In recent times, close-range photogrammetry (CRP) based on unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) a... ver más
Revista: Infrastructures

 
Mohamed Sameer Hoosain, Babu Sena Paul, Wesley Doorsamy and Seeram Ramakrishna    
The United Nations Member States created a common roadmap for sustainability and development in 2015. The UN-SDGs are included in the 2030 Plan as an immediate call to action from all nations in the form of global partnerships. To date, a handful of coun... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Nelson Carriço, Bruno Ferreira, André Antunes, João Caetano and Dídia Covas    
This paper presents a set of computational tools specially developed for supporting the operation and management of water distribution systems towards digital transformation of water services. These tools were developed in the scope of two R&D projec... ver más
Revista: Water