ARTÍCULO
TITULO

A Ranking List for Information Systems Journals

Julie Fisher    
Graeme Shanks    
John W Lamp    

Resumen

There has been an increasing focus internationally on the quality and impact of research outputs in recent years. Several countries, including the United Kingdom and New Zealand have implemented schemes to base the funding of research on research quality. The Australian government is planning to implement a Research Quality Framework (RQF) in the next few years that will impact greatly on funding of research in Australian universities. A key issue for Australian researchers is how the quality and impact of research is defined and measured in their discipline areas. Although peer review is widely used to assess the quality of research outputs, it is expensive and labour intensive. Other surrogate quality measures are often used. This paper focuses on measuring the quality of research outputs in the information systems discipline. We argue that measures such as citation indexes are inappropriate for information systems and that the publication outlet is a more suitable indicator of quality. We present a ranking list of journals for the information systems discipline, and discuss the approach we have taken in developing the list. We discuss how the ranking list may be used in defining and measuring the quality of information systems research outputs, the limitations inherent in the approach and discuss lessons we have learned in developing the list.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Jirí Ambros, Jirí Sedoník     Pág. 2054 - 2063
Network safety ranking (or hotspot identification) is conducted in order to identify hazardous road locations and develop a priority list for application of effective safety treatments. In this process empirical Bayes approach, using accident prediction ... ver más

 
Chidambaram Ramanathan, S P Narayanan, Arazi B Idrus     Pág. 37 - 57
There is an increase in the number of construction projects experiencing extensive delays leading to exceeding initial time and cost budget.  This paper reviews 41 studies around the world which surveyed the delay factors and classified them into Gr... ver más

 
John W Lamp,Julie Fisher    
The Excellence in Research for Australia (ERA) initiative being conducted by the Australian Research Council (ARC), mandates a single journal and conference ranking scheme over every academic discipline in Australia. A universal publication outlet rankin... ver más

 
Julie Fisher,Graeme Shanks,John W Lamp    
In 2007 we published a paper describing the approach the Australian Council of Professors and Heads of Information Systems (ACPHIS) had used in developing a ranked list of information systems journals. In late 2007 more details became available on the DE... ver más