ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Criteria in consultant selection: public procurement of architectural and engineering services

Josefin Sporrong    

Resumen

The competence, commitment and attitudes of design consultants strongly influence the quality and costs of built facilities. However, in the selection of professional services it is often difficult to specify and assess non-price criteria related to both firms and individual consultants. Therefore, clients traditionally rely on long term relations or recommendations from clients or colleagues. Public procurement regulation, however, restricts the use of such informal data. This study seeks to understand how procurers act to reconcile these conflicting demands.An explorative questionnaire survey distributed to Swedish municipalities investigates which selection criteria and information sources are used, as well as perceived difficulties and shortcomings related to consultancy procurement. Results show a high focus on price or more easily measured non-price criteria. This might limit the ability of municipal officials to evaluate consultant competence, especially aspects related to design and execution of projects. Furthermore, personal information sources are widely used, indicating a conflict between procurement practice and existing regulation. Unexpectedly, procurement officials were generally satisfied with their procurement practice. However, managers and more experienced procurers tend to be more satisfied than other officials. Satisfaction also appears to be connected to the existence of a procurement policy and more advanced selection methods. Keywords: public procurement, selection, consultants, Sweden

 Artículos similares

       
 
Guoqian Ren, Haijiang Li and Jisong Zhang    
Public-private partnerships (PPPs) have proliferated and adapted to public development in recent decades; within it, the value for money (VfM) assessment defines the feasibility of the project procurement model as one of the essential components of PPP. ... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Tharun Dolla, Boeing Laishram     Pág. Article ID
Prequalification (PQ) is a significant process in the selection of private sector for the delivery of civil infrastructure projects.  But, the extant literature, for the most part, focused on PQ of construction projects.  The need for setting p... ver más

 
Patrizia Beraldi, Antonio Violi, Maria Elena Bruni and Gianluca Carrozzino    
The definition of the electric energy procurement plan represents a fundamental problem that any consumer has to deal with. Bilateral contracts, electricity market and self-production are the main supply sources that should be properly combined to satisf... ver más
Revista: Energies

 
Lisa Hansson, Johan Holmgren     Pág. 2450 - 2460
One of the official transport policy objectives in Sweden is that all citizens should have access to the transport system. The public sector is therefore required by law to provide special transport services (STS) for those who are unable to use public t... ver más

 
Fred Amonya     Pág. 5291 - 5306
The path from policy to service delivery is not always clear. The technology, including engineering and management, may not be known. Consequently, the public sector invites the private sector to participate in devising the specification. That is the ess... ver más