Inicio  /  Water  /  Vol: 15 Par: 23 (2023)  /  Artículo
ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Performance of LSTM over SWAT in Rainfall-Runoff Modeling in a Small, Forested Watershed: A Case Study of Cork Brook, RI

Shiva Gopal Shrestha and Soni M. Pradhanang    

Resumen

The general practice of rainfall-runoff model development towards physically based and spatially explicit representations of hydrological processes is data-intensive and computationally expensive. Physically based models such as the Soil Water Assessment tool (SWAT) demand spatio-temporal data and expert knowledge. Also, the difficulty and complexity is compounded in the smaller watershed due to data constraint and models? inability to generalize hydrologic processes. Data-driven models can bridge this gap with their mathematical formulation. Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) is a data-driven model with Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) architecture, which is better suited to solve time series problems. Studies have shown that LSTM models have competitive performance in watershed hydrology studies. In this study, a comparative analysis of SWAT and LSTM models in the Cork Brook watershed shows that results from LSTM were competitive to SWAT in flow prediction with NSE of 0.6 against 0.63, respectively, given the limited availability of data. LSTM models do not overestimate the high flows like SWAT. However, both these models struggle with low values estimation. Although interpretability, explainability, and use of models across different datasets or events outside of the training data may be challenging, LSTM models are robust and efficient.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Junling Zhang, Min Mei, Jun Wang, Guangpeng Shang, Xuefeng Hu, Jing Yan and Qian Fang    
The deformation of tunnel support structures during tunnel construction is influenced by geological factors, geometrical factors, support factors, and construction factors. Accurate prediction of tunnel support structure deformation is crucial for engine... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Yongen Lin, Dagang Wang, Tao Jiang and Aiqing Kang    
Reliable streamflow forecasting is a determining factor for water resource planning and flood control. To better understand the strengths and weaknesses of newly proposed methods in streamflow forecasting and facilitate comparisons of different research ... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Feifei He, Qinjuan Wan, Yongqiang Wang, Jiang Wu, Xiaoqi Zhang and Yu Feng    
Accurately predicting hydrological runoff is crucial for water resource allocation and power station scheduling. However, there is no perfect model that can accurately predict future runoff. In this paper, a daily runoff prediction method with a seasonal... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Haibo Chu, Zhuoqi Wang and Chong Nie    
Accurate and reliable monthly streamflow prediction plays a crucial role in the scientific allocation and efficient utilization of water resources. In this paper, we proposed a prediction framework that integrates the input variable selection method and ... ver más
Revista: Water

 
Yussuf Ahmed, Muhammad Ajmal Azad and Taufiq Asyhari    
In recent years, there has been a notable surge in both the complexity and volume of targeted cyber attacks, largely due to heightened vulnerabilities in widely adopted technologies. The Prediction and detection of early attacks are vital to mitigating p... ver más
Revista: Information