Inicio  /  Water  /  Vol: 9 Núm: 9 Par: 0 (2017)  /  Artículo
ARTÍCULO
TITULO

Stimulating Learning through Policy Experimentation: A Multi-Case Analysis of How Design Influences Policy Learning Outcomes in Experiments for Climate Adaptation

Belinda McFadgen    
Dave Huitema    

Resumen

Learning from policy experimentation is a promising way to approach the ?wicked problem? of climate adaptation, which is characterised by knowledge gaps and contested understandings of future risk. However, although the role of learning in shaping public policy is well understood, and experiments are expected to facilitate learning, little is known about how experiments produce learning, what types of learning, and how they can be designed to enhance learning effects. Using quantitative research methods, we explore how design choices influence the learning experiences of 173 participants in 18 policy experiments conducted in the Netherlands between 1997 and 2016. The experiments are divided into three ?ideal types? that are expected to produce different levels and types of learning. The findings show that policy experiments produce cognitive and relational learning effects, but less normative learning, and experiment design influenced three of six measured dimensions of learning, especially the cognitive learning dimensions. This reveals a trade-off between designing for knowledge development and designing for normative or relational changes; choices that experiment designers should make in the context of their adaptation problem. Our findings also show the role leadership plays in building trust.

 Artículos similares

       
 
Shiva Raj Pokhrel, Jonathan Kua, Deol Satish, Sebnem Ozer, Jeff Howe and Anwar Walid    
We introduce a novel multipath data transport approach at the transport layer referred to as ?Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient for Multipath Performance-oriented Congestion Control? (DDPG-MPCC), which leverages deep reinforcement learning to enhance co... ver más
Revista: Future Internet

 
Chen Zhang, Celimuge Wu, Min Lin, Yangfei Lin and William Liu    
In the advanced 5G and beyond networks, multi-access edge computing (MEC) is increasingly recognized as a promising technology, offering the dual advantages of reducing energy utilization in cloud data centers while catering to the demands for reliabilit... ver más
Revista: Future Internet

 
Juyao Wei, Zhenggang Lu, Zheng Yin and Zhipeng Jing    
This paper presents a novel data-driven multiagent reinforcement learning (MARL) controller for enhancing the running stability of independently rotating wheels (IRW) and reducing wheel?rail wear. We base our active guidance controller on the multiagent ... ver más
Revista: Applied Sciences

 
Jiacun Wang, Guipeng Xi, Xiwang Guo, Shujin Qin and Henry Han    
The scheduling of disassembly lines is of great importance to achieve optimized productivity. In this paper, we address the Hybrid Disassembly Line Balancing Problem that combines linear disassembly lines and U-shaped disassembly lines, considering multi... ver más
Revista: Information

 
Yu-Hung Chang, Chien-Hung Liu and Shingchern D. You    
The dynamic flexible job-shop problem (DFJSP) is a realistic and challenging problem that many production plants face. As the product line becomes more complex, the machines may suddenly break down or resume service, so we need a dynamic scheduling frame... ver más
Revista: Information